Graham/Oppenheimer lead team to defense verdict in Escambia County jury trial

Graham/Oppenheimer lead team to defense verdict in Escambia County jury trial

Duane Graham and Harris Oppenheimer recently obtained a jury verdict in favor of an oil company after a fourteen day trial in Escambia County, Alabama.  The plaintiffs alleged drainage and waste of oil, together with fraud and wantonness, relating to defendants’ well on property adjacent to the plaintiffs’ property. Defendants successfully proved to the jury’s satisfaction that there was no recoverable oil located underneath the plaintiffs’ property.  Plaintiffs’ counsel asked for a verdict of $128,000,000 in closing argument.  The jury returned with a defense verdict in a little more than one hour.

Sign up for our Newsletter

Hume leads team to defense verdict in Monroe County jury trial

Hume leads team to defense verdict in Monroe County jury trial

Chris Hume and Jim Koch obtained a verdict in favor of a commercial truck driver and his company after a seven day jury trial in Monroe County, Alabama.  The 72 year old plaintiff alleged that the defendant was negligent and wanton for attempting to pass the plaintiff in a no-passing zone and failing to keep a proper lookout while distracted by a diagnostic tool in the cab of his Freightliner.  In the ensuing collision, the plaintiff, ejected from his pick-up truck, suffered a traumatic brain injury and fractures of his clavicle, scapula, ribs, spine, skull and jaw and was LifeFlighted from Monroeville to Mobile.  Plaintiff’s wife claimed a loss of consortium.  Defendant successfully asserted a defense of contributory negligence based on plaintiff’s failure to yield the right-of-way by pulling out in front of the defendant causing the defendant to take evasive action to avoid rear-ending the plaintiff.  Plaintiffs’ counsel asked for a verdict of $1,335,821 on the negligence and wantonness counts in closing argument.  The jury returned with a defense verdict in a little over an hour.  

Sign up for our Newsletter